The migration in scale and structure
The UNESCO Memory of the World inscription describes a voluntary migration of “more than 50,000 Anglo-West-Indian labourers, [who] migrated to the Isthmus of Panama some of whom were followed by their wives. For these thousands of West Indians voluntary separation from home and family represented an unimaginable promise of economic improvement” [1]. The migration spanned the French canal attempt of 1881–1889 and the American construction project of 1904–1914, and it was a major movement of Caribbean labor to the Isthmus before the West Indian professional migrations of the 1950s and 1960s.
The records that UNESCO inscribed include manuscripts (Reports, Police Reports documenting migration), photographs and images, postcards, bank deposit ledgers recording what were called “Panama Money” entries in Savings Banks, and Canal Zone stamps that facilitated communication between the laborers and their relatives back home. The nominating institutions were the Barbados Department of Archives, the Jamaica Archives, Panama’s Museo del Canal Interoceánico, the University of Florida’s George A. Smathers Library, and the National Archives of the United Kingdom and the United States. The inscription was placed on both the UNESCO Memory of the World International Register and the Regional Register for Latin America and the Caribbean under ID 54/2011 [1].
Why the Caribbean migrants came
The post-emancipation Caribbean of the 1880s offered limited economic opportunity. After British emancipation in 1834, the West Indian laboring classes faced falling sugar prices, contracting plantation employment, and growing population pressure on small islands. The French canal project, recruiting from Barbados and other islands, offered wages substantially above what was available at home. The American canal project that began in 1904 expanded recruitment and added Martinique and Guadeloupe to the source regions. The U.S. National Archives’ “Rediscovering Black History” blog post on West Indian canal employees summarizes: “Workers came from Barbados, Jamaica, Grenada, Martinique, and Trinidad. They came to the Canal Zone looking for better employment opportunities and improved working conditions but also experienced racial discrimination” [2].
The migration was overwhelmingly voluntary, in contrast to the enslaved African labor that had built Portobelo and the earlier Spanish colonial infrastructure. Recruiters, formally called “labor agents”, worked from Caribbean ports and signed individual contracts. The French canal company paid a fixed sum per worker; the American Isthmian Canal Commission recruited through a similar labor-agent system. The migrants typically arrived in groups, were housed in barrack-style accommodations near the work sites, and were paid partly in Panamanian currency and partly in “Panama Money” (credit at the Canal Zone commissaries that could be remitted home as bank deposits through the Savings Bank system the UNESCO inscription describes).
What they did on the canal
The West Indian workers were “a major group of people employed by the Panama Canal” during the construction era, according to the National Archives [2]. They were employed as laborers to dig, clear the land, and level or grade the earth in order to build the Miraflores Locks or the Gatun Dam. Their work was dangerous; mortality among West Indian laborers during the early American construction years was heavy, and the unequal burden was one of the complaints that critics of the segregated employment system raised.
The National Archives’ record series for this workforce includes: Applications for Photo-Metal Check 1918-1919 (NAID 6821421), Metal Check Issue Cards 1930-1937 (NAID 7226555), Sailing List of Contract Laborers 1905-1913 (NAID 7226554), and Labor Service Contracts 1905-1913 (NAID 7351398). Vital records include Marriage Licenses 1904-1979, Clergy Marriage Registration Books 1904-1979, Registers of Birth 1910-1928, Records of Deaths 1905-1949, and Death Certificate Cards 1914-1915. The Gorgas Hospital Mortuary Registers 1906-1991 are searchable by nationality through the National Archives’ AAD (Access to Archival Databases) system [2].
The Silver Men designation and the rolls
The “Silver Men” title of the UNESCO inscription comes from the Canal Zone’s two-roll employment system, in which West Indian laborers were assigned to the “Silver Roll” with lower pay, restricted housing, and separate facilities from the white “Gold Roll” employees. The system was enforced throughout the canal era and was the subject of formal complaints and memos from the canal’s own leadership. Chairman Goethals wrote a 1910 memo acknowledging racial discrimination, and Acting Chairman Hodges wrote a similar memo the same year. The rolls were not officially abolished until the mid-1950s, although Gold and Silver roll designations were replaced by “U.S.-rate” and “local-rate” in 1948.
The “Silver Men” naming is, by the UNESCO inscription’s own account, a deliberate echo of the Silver Roll designation, and the inscription is in part a recognition that the records being preserved are the documentary evidence of a community that the Canal Zone Government’s own employment system classified as second-class.
What happened to the community after 1914
The American canal’s 1914 completion did not end the West Indian presence on the Isthmus; it ended the construction-era mass migration but left a settled community that continued to work on the canal’s operation, on the Panama Railroad, in the Zone’s commissaries and service industries, and in the emerging commercial districts of Panama City and Colón. By 2014, an estimated 60,000-70,000 descendants of West Indians were living in Panama [3], with major concentrations in the Río Abajo neighborhood of Panama City and in the city of Colón. The community maintained its own churches, schools, social clubs, and newspapers through the 20th century, and the Afro-Antillean Museum of Panama, established in 1980 by the anthropologist Reina Torres de Arauz [4], is the institutional center of the community’s historical memory.
The 2011 UNESCO inscription recognized that the documentary record of this community is now distributed across archives in Barbados, Jamaica, Panama, the United States, and the United Kingdom, and that no single national archive could adequately preserve or interpret it. The inscription is therefore in part a coordination mechanism. It makes the various archives’ holdings mutually visible and creates a shared reference point that researchers can use across jurisdictions. For Panamanian researchers today, the UNESCO entry on The Silver Men is a useful starting point for tracing any individual West Indian laborer who came to the Isthmus between 1880 and 1914.
What the migration meant for the receiving country
The migration’s effects on Panama were substantial and outlasted the canal construction itself. By the 1920s, Colón and Panama City had large West Indian communities, including many Panama-born children of the original migrants; the West Indian community contributed the workforce that built and operated the canal’s commissaries, services, and administrative offices; and the West Indian presence shaped the cultural and religious life of the major Panamanian cities. The Spanish-language literary and folkloric traditions of Panama City and Colón include West Indian contributions that are still visible today: the calypso and reggae scenes, the West Indian-owned rum shops and bakeries, the Protestant church traditions that are stronger in the West Indian neighborhoods than in the rest of Panama, and the Afro-Antillean Spanish dialect that is still spoken by some older Panamanians in Río Abajo and Colón [3].
The 1926 immigration restrictions on West Indians, combined with the broader Canal Zone policy of restricting the Gold Roll to white Americans, formalized a hierarchy that had previously been implicit. By 1940, the West Indian community in Panama was substantially settled (second- and third-generation Panamanians of West Indian descent were the majority), but their legal status remained ambiguous, with the 1941 constitution under Arnulfo Arias attempting to revoke citizenship for many. The 1946 constitution reversed that change and re-affirmed citizenship by birth in Panama.
Where to follow the community today
Three institutional anchors keep the West Indian community’s history visible. The Afro-Antillean Museum in Panama City, established in 1980 by the anthropologist Reina Torres de Arauz, is a principal museum and an accessible starting point for a visitor. The UNESCO Memory of the World inscription for The Silver Men provides the international documentation framework. The community newspapers (particularly The Panama Tribune, founded by Sidney Adolphus Young in 1928 and which ran for 44 years) are a substantial surviving record of the West Indian community’s internal life.
For a researcher, useful archives include the Barbados Department of Archives and the Jamaica Archives, both of which hold extensive records of the migration’s origin; the U.S. National Archives’ Record Group 185, which holds the official Canal Zone records; the Panama Canal Museum Collection at the University of Florida; and Panama’s own Archivo General de la Nación. The community’s oral history is held most actively in the family networks of the West Indian diaspora in Panama, the United States, the United Kingdom, and the Caribbean.
West Indian settlements across the Isthmus
The West Indian diaspora in Panama was not concentrated only in the two terminal cities. Wikipedia’s entry on Afro-Panamanians confirms that descendants of the canal-era West Indian migrants settled in several distinct communities across the Isthmus: the towns and cities of Colón, Cristóbal, and Balboa on the Atlantic side; the Río Abajo area of Panama City on the Pacific side; the former Canal Zone itself; and, distinct from all of these, the province of Bocas del Toro on the Caribbean coast, where Afro-Antillean banana-plantation workers had been recruited by the United Fruit Company from the 1880s onward in a separate migration stream that predated and then overlapped with the canal recruitment [3]. The geographic spread of the community is one of the reasons the UNESCO inscription was placed on both the International Register and the Regional Register for Latin America and the Caribbean. The surviving documentary record is genuinely transnational, distributed across archives in Barbados, Jamaica, Panama, the United States, and the United Kingdom.
The Bocas del Toro community is linguistically distinctive: Afro-Antillean English-lexifier creole survived in the province into the 21st century as Bocas del Toro Creole, alongside the Spanish of the broader Panamanian population [3]. The maintenance of an English-lexifier creole in a Spanish-speaking country is unusual and is one of the more visible inheritances of the canal-era and banana-era West Indian migrations. The Afro-Panamanian musical tradition that grew out of the West Indian community (particularly the Panamanian Spanish-language reggae and reggaeton scenes that took shape in the 1980s and 1990s) is another continuing legacy of the same migration chain. El General (Edgardo Franco), often credited as the first artist to blend reggae with Spanish-language lyrics and a foundational figure of the broader reggaeton genre, was from the Río Abajo neighborhood of Panama City and grew up in a West Indian-descended community [3].
Last reviewed: